@gnorium Fill every field of this object that its scan or a source establishes, and submit it as one revision. Read the object first, then the title page and colophon frames. Give every claim a citation: the Source URL of the IIIF manifest it comes from, the frame, and the quote that states it, exactly as printed. For the origins, cite the earliest edition that has the text. Leave a field empty where nothing establishes it; fill nothing from memory.
@gnorium Fill every field of this object that its scan or a source establishes, and submit it as one revision. Read the object first, then the title page and colophon frames. Give every claim a citation: the Source URL of the IIIF manifest it comes from, the frame, and the quote that states it, exactly as printed. For the origins, cite the earliest edition that has the text. Leave a field empty where nothing establishes it; fill nothing from memory.
@gnorium Fill out the object form fields completely.
@gnorium Fill out the object form fields completely.
@gnorium Fill out the object form fields completely.
@gnorium Fill out the object form fields completely.
@gnorium Three things in this object are incomplete. (1) The work’s date is the date Hamlet was written, not this edition’s 1603: find and support it. (2) “Devonshire (Chatsworth library)” is not a person: replace it with each Duke of Devonshire who held the book from 1823 to 1914, with his dates, and add the buyer of 1914. (3) Support each step of the Origin, not only the last. Read the object first and keep everything else as it is unless incorrect. Use full name for former owners, like “Sir Henry Edward Bunbury, 7th Baronet”.
@gnorium Three things in this object are incomplete. (1) The work’s date is the date Hamlet was written, not this edition’s 1603: find and support it. (2) “Devonshire (Chatsworth library)” is not a person: replace it with each Duke of Devonshire who held the book from 1823 to 1914, with his dates, and add the buyer of 1914. (3) Support each step of the Origin, not only the last. Read the object first and keep everything else as it is unless incorrect. Use full name for former owners, like "Sir Henry Edward Bunbury, 7th Baronet".
@gnorium Read the object first (read_object) and keep everything in it that is not named below: do not redo fields that are done. This is a correction pass on the Hamlet overture. File one suggest_revision.
Voices. Every source you cite has an empty Voice list. Give each source its voices, read from its title page, by role (author, translator, compiler; an editor only for a work that is theirs to edit, such as a dictionary), the name in natural order. This is how Gnorium finds the record of that work, so a source with no voices becomes a duplicate. Do this for the Dictionary of national biography, the Dictionary of American biography, the Oxford Companion, the census of Shakespeare’s plays and the Works of William Shakespeare, each of which your sources cite more than once; the same work cited from different scans has the same voices.
Former owners. A row is one owner: never change an existing row into a different person; remove it and add the right one. Order them by when each held the copy, earliest first (Hanmer, then the Bunbury line, Payne & Foss, the Dukes, Huntington). Each row’s period is the years the owner held this copy, from the quote you cite, never the owner’s birth and death years. Remove “Devonshire (Chatsworth library)” if it is still there as an owner. Where a quote gives no year of holding, leave the period empty rather than filling in a lifespan.
Supports must name a row. Move the whole-list supports (“Genres”, “Former owners”) to the single row each quote supports: read_object lists them in wholeListClaims, each with its row key (genres:<id>, formerOwners:<id>). Do not file a support for a list as a whole.
Origin. The chain Hamlet → Belleforest → Saxo rests on a school module (“English 30. Module 5. Hamlet”). Support each step from a scholarly source instead: use search_sources and read the frames, citing the Oxford Companion for Saxo, and find one for Belleforest’s Histoires tragiques and for the Hamlet-to-Belleforest step. Keep that module only where nothing better says it. Origin 1.1 (Belleforest) has the year qualifier “Exact” with no year: give the year (1576, from the quote) or remove the qualifier.
Date. The work’s date (1599–1602) is the date Hamlet was written, supported now by the same school module. Support it from a scholarly source, or say in your reason that you found none.
Cite only what you read in a frame; each quote is whole sentences, and a quote you cannot find stays out. Give your reason for each change in one sentence.
@gnorium Read the object first (read_object) and keep everything in it that is not named below: do not redo fields that are done. This is a correction pass on the Hamlet overture. File one suggest_revision.
1. Voices. Every source you cite has an empty Voice list. Give each source its voices, read from its title page, by role (author, translator, compiler; an editor only for a work that is theirs to edit, such as a dictionary), the name in natural order. This is how Gnorium finds the record of that work, so a source with no voices becomes a duplicate. Do this for the Dictionary of national biography, the Dictionary of American biography, the Oxford Companion, the census of Shakespeare's plays and the Works of William Shakespeare, each of which your sources cite more than once; the same work cited from different scans has the same voices.
2. Former owners. A row is one owner: never change an existing row into a different person; remove it and add the right one. Order them by when each held the copy, earliest first (Hanmer, then the Bunbury line, Payne & Foss, the Dukes, Huntington). Each row's period is the years the owner held this copy, from the quote you cite, never the owner's birth and death years. Remove "Devonshire (Chatsworth library)" if it is still there as an owner. Where a quote gives no year of holding, leave the period empty rather than filling in a lifespan.
3. Supports must name a row. Move the whole-list supports ("Genres", "Former owners") to the single row each quote supports: read_object lists them in wholeListClaims, each with its row key (genres:<id>, formerOwners:<id>). Do not file a support for a list as a whole.
4. Origin. The chain Hamlet → Belleforest → Saxo rests on a school module ("English 30. Module 5. Hamlet"). Support each step from a scholarly source instead: use search_sources and read the frames, citing the Oxford Companion for Saxo, and find one for Belleforest's Histoires tragiques and for the Hamlet-to-Belleforest step. Keep that module only where nothing better says it. Origin 1.1 (Belleforest) has the year qualifier "Exact" with no year: give the year (1576, from the quote) or remove the qualifier.
5. Date. The work's date (1599–1602) is the date Hamlet was written, supported now by the same school module. Support it from a scholarly source, or say in your reason that you found none.
Cite only what you read in a frame; each quote is whole sentences, and a quote you cannot find stays out. Give your reason for each change in one sentence.@gnorium Bring this whole overture to a crystalline state: every field correct, sourced and complete. Work in rounds until a round finds nothing to fix.
Round structure
read_objectthe whole overture. List every fault you find, by node and field, before changing anything.Split the work among subagents with
spawn_subagent, one per node: the work, origins 1–1.1.1, testament 1, copy 1.1 and digitization 1.1.1. Each subagent finds sources for its node’s claims and returns supports with quotes read word for word from frames it read.Check every suggestion with
suggest_revisionandcheck: truefirst, fix what it refuses, then file it.After filing,
read_objectagain and critique the result as a hostile reviewer would. Look for anything unsourced, imprecise, out of order, duplicated or inconsistent between nodes. Start another round on what you find. Stop only when a full round files nothing, and say so.
Known faults to fix first
Origins.
1 is the lost Ur-Hamlet, author unknown (Thomas Kyd possible, not certain), before 1589. Shakespeare is not its author.
1.1 is Belleforest’s tale Avec quelle ruse Amleth, qui depuis fut Roy de Dannemarch, vengea la mort de son pere Horuuendille, occis par Fengon son frere, et autre occurrence de son histoire (short story, French), first printed 1570; it is not the whole Cinquiesme Tome of 1576.
1.1.1 is Gesta Danorum, dated as a range of 1185–1208.
Copy 1.1, former owners.
Order them chronologically by start date.
Give every dated owner a year qualifier.
Find dates for Hanmer and Bunbury, or state why none can be found.
Set certainty from the evidence, not by default.
Copy 1.1, other fields.
The call number scheme.
A reference: the Huntington catalog record and/or ESTC.
Digitization 1.1.1: its agent (role and name), date and reference, from the Huntington’s own record of the image.
Supports
Every claim of every node has at least one support from the source that established it (see your source rule). A claim without one is a fault.
When the same quotes back several claims of a node, file one support naming all of those claims, never one support per claim. Merge existing supports that repeat the same quotes: keep one id and remove the others.
Point a whole-list claim (genres, former owners) at its rows.
Remove supports that are stale, whose claim no longer exists or whose quote no longer says it.
Forms are the words alone, never the punctuation around them.
Report
At the end, report:
each round’s faults found and fixed;
what you could not settle, and why;
a final statement that the last round found nothing.
@gnorium Bring this whole overture to a crystalline state: every field correct, sourced and complete. Work in rounds until a round finds nothing to fix. ## Round structure 1. `read_object` the whole overture. List every fault you find, by node and field, before changing anything. 2. Split the work among subagents with `spawn_subagent`, one per node: the work, origins 1–1.1.1, testament 1, copy 1.1 and digitization 1.1.1. Each subagent finds sources for its node's claims and returns supports with quotes read word for word from frames it read. 3. Check every suggestion with `suggest_revision` and `check: true` first, fix what it refuses, then file it. 4. After filing, `read_object` again and critique the result as a hostile reviewer would. Look for anything unsourced, imprecise, out of order, duplicated or inconsistent between nodes. Start another round on what you find. Stop only when a full round files nothing, and say so. ## Known faults to fix first - **Origins.** - 1 is the lost Ur-Hamlet, author unknown (Thomas Kyd possible, not certain), before 1589. Shakespeare is not its author. - 1.1 is Belleforest's tale *Avec quelle ruse Amleth, qui depuis fut Roy de Dannemarch, vengea la mort de son pere Horuuendille, occis par Fengon son frere, et autre occurrence de son histoire* (short story, French), first printed 1570; it is not the whole *Cinquiesme Tome* of 1576. - 1.1.1 is *Gesta Danorum*, dated as a range of 1185–1208. - **Copy 1.1, former owners.** - Order them chronologically by start date. - Give every dated owner a year qualifier. - Find dates for Hanmer and Bunbury, or state why none can be found. - Set certainty from the evidence, not by default. - **Copy 1.1, other fields.** - The call number scheme. - A reference: the Huntington catalog record and/or ESTC. - **Digitization 1.1.1:** its agent (role and name), date and reference, from the Huntington's own record of the image. ## Supports - Every claim of every node has at least one support from the source that established it (see your source rule). A claim without one is a fault. - When the same quotes back several claims of a node, file **one support naming all of those claims**, never one support per claim. Merge existing supports that repeat the same quotes: keep one id and remove the others. - Point a whole-list claim (genres, former owners) at its rows. - Remove supports that are stale, whose claim no longer exists or whose quote no longer says it. - Forms are the words alone, never the punctuation around them. ## Report At the end, report: - each round's faults found and fixed; - what you could not settle, and why; - a final statement that the last round found nothing.